Founded on Oct. 1, 2010

News & Entertainment for Mason City, Clear Lake & the Entire North Iowa Region

DON’T MISS NIT’S SUBSCRIBER-ONLY STORIESExclusive North Iowa reporting · Just $24 for 6 monthsUNLOCK STORIES
Magic Mike's Detail - Before and after detailing. Click here to call for appointment at 641-530-2620
News Archives

Judge Colleen Weiland considering new sentence for convicted murderer Damion Seats

Facebook
Tumblr
Threads
X
LinkedIn
Email
Judge Colleen Weiland
Judge Colleen Weiland

MASON CITY – A judge known by many in North Iowa for extreme leniency is considering a new sentence for a man convicted as a 17-year-old of murder.

Damion Seats, now 22 years of age, was transported back to Mason City this week, where he and two other teens shot and killed Isidoro Erreguin, 28, at a North End house in August of 2008. Seats has been serving a life sentence since 2009 after being convicted of 1st degree murder. He was also sentenced to 25 years in prison – to run concurrently – for 1st degree burglary.

Now, Seats has demanded a new sentence in the case, as some say the sentence was too harsh due to the fact that Seats was not a legal adult at the time of the crime. He was in court Friday where Judge Colleen Weiland heard arguments for and against a sentence change for Seats.

Weiland – who earlier this year sentenced a Clarion man who had faced up to 25 years in prison for breaking an infant’s legs to a suspended jail sentence – is expected to make a ruling early next week.

What do you think… should Weiland go easy on Seats, or send him back to Fort Madison for life?

Facebook
Tumblr
Threads
X
LinkedIn
Email
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of

42 LEAVE A COMMENT2!

Libtard monkey lover!

If this young man gets a lighter sentence I will vomit. I know him and the question was never IF he would take a life. The question was WHEN. No regard for authority, rules, laws, or life. I will guarantee one thing and that is if he is let out of prison at ANY time, he will kill again. Keep him behind bars until he dies.

How about this: if a judge lets someone off easy and that person commits another crime, that judge is then charged with aiding and abetting a criminal…just an idea.

…I have said this before, and I will continue to say this…Prisons will “never” be overcrowded until they can’t close the door or nobody can sit down! Take all my tax dollars you want…and build more prisons…doing that provides for more well paying jobs for the rest of us!

Give me a break! All you clowns want everyone to receive a maximum sentence until it’s YOU before the judge. Then you want leniency.

“Bo” you are correct but it seems like she is always the judge that is in the paper for this kind of stuff. 18 should be the legal age and that goes for voting, drinking, entering the service. What ever happened to the other 2 young me that was with Seats in this murder trial?

There is more than likely a lot of back room dealing going on when the judge (doesn’t matter which one) gives a lesser sentence than you would like. And in some cases that is probably a good thing because most back room dealing revolves around turning in other offenders. Those other offenders are the ones who supply or finance more than one dealer. The judge in this case will do what the county attorney wants. It is that person who makes the deals and then presents the case to the court.
In addition, our prisons are overflowing now. When one person is admitted to prison, someone else has to be released to make room for the new one.
And Nichole is correct. The new sentencing comes from a higher court ruling that says all juveniles who have been sentenced to life imprisonment need to have their sentencing reviewed. It does not say they have to be released but it makes the point that life imprisonment for juveniles shouldn’t be a cut and dried decision. I know you who disagree will howl that a 17 year old knows what he did is wrong and you are right. But where do we draw the line? At 12? At 14? At 6? Tough question.

She is a worthless judge and should be empeached by the govenor. Just today that ferdon kid got his 3rd owi and guess who gave him a free pass? This lady sho calls herself a judge. What a waste of a position. Shw must be a pill popper (sleeping pills) cause she cant sleep normal knowing all the fricken idiots she has let go.

yep thats cerro gordo for u just like in oglesby case kaleb Tyler broke in house assaults him with a sledge hammer he gets 3 rd degree criminal mistchief should have been b& e and attepted attempted murder instead they try to put oglesby in prison for 17 years for defending him self kaleb is grandson of ex cop dave Tyler grandma ann worked at county attorney office det Duane kemna wouldn’t alow oglesby to press charges on Tyler even though proof was over wellming there all corrupt and dirty cops likd kemba give any decent law officers a bad name i wouldn’t pee on any of them if they were on fire funny how they say they accidently chargeed oglesby after he turned them into fbi and department of justice there all dirty serve and protect what a joke

i knew him pretty well and letting this kid back on the streets would result in another murder in near future, this judge needs to be fired immediately. and to the dumb ass who thinks he should be let out. He ran in a home killed a man that was sleeping that he didnt even know. why should this peice of shit be given a reduced sentence?

She will probably give him probation just like she does with all the other criminals. IOWA SUCKS is an IDIOT.

Leave this judge alone NIT! If we put everyone in prison you’d like in prison, more people would be in prison than out! Reserve prison for violent offenders! And that’s what this good judge does.

This judge is very lenient. I think she’s lenient because she’s afraid to use the power her position gives her. I have to admit, it would be a job that I wouldn’t want. I would be afraid of having these loser criminals back on the street after handing them a severe sentence. Still, that’s what we taxpayers pay for. If she can’t do the job, maybe it’s just too scary, and time to move on.

Good job NIT for bringing this to the public.

Extreme leniency? Give me a break!

Do you think you’d be safer by destroying everyone’s lives permanently that comes before her court for any crime? You’d be less safe in the long run, because most everyone gets out of prison at some point and desperate people do desperate things.

Enough of this biased crap NIT! You’re no goody goody, perfect people yourselves. We should put people in prison who are a danger to others, not those we simply dislike. When you destroy a persons ability to make money and live a normal life you are, in effect making things less safe.

Screwballs like LVS posting his hater crap is one thing, but it shouldn’t come from NIT stories.

You are not perfect by a long shot yourself.

At 17, you know right from wrong. He should not get a reduced sentence.

This is because of United States and Iowa Supreme Court rulings.

42
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x