The city has told Tip Piper that his apple tree has a “visibility” complaint issue, that it is dying, and that it will be removed. City workers came out to Piper’s property and painted white “X’s” on the tree. Piper disagrees, and will take the matter to the Zoning Board of Adjustment.
Piper, who lives at 2303 21st Street SW, says the tree is decades old and is part of his family’s heritage. Piper says he had no trouble until he asked for a stop sign to be placed at the corner of S. Grover and 21st Street SW. He asked for the sign, he says, due to the traffic from the nearby Newman Schools. Piper says once he asked for the sign, city officials began pointing out code issues on his property.
Robert Berggren, Mason City Street/Park Maint. Supervisor, wrote Piper the following email: “Mr. Piper, The tree you are referring to is dying and needs to be removed. It is also part of a visibility complaint that was called into the City Engineers office. There are also many bushes and shrubs on your property that need to be trimmed down to 3 feet in height or removed from the corner.”
Piper is left to wonder if by “trying to make the intersection safer with a stop sign” he may have “created a monster.” He says he just wants his tree (and shrubs) left alone.
Piper says the apple tree serves his family in many ways, including providing shade, not to mention the delicious apples it still produces. “We make apple pies from the apples, to this day. It is not dying,” Piper said. The tree has some visible storm damage, but fresh fruit could be readily found hanging from its branches. Piper says his mother, who is 93 years old and just home from the hospital, is very attached to the tree, as is his son, who is due to return from military service in Afghanistan. He says they both would be “very upset” at losing the tree.
Piper placed signs on the tree asking city workers not to cut the tree down until he has a chance to take the matter to the City’s Zoning Board. There, he can apply for a variance in order to save the tree.
Piper says that no city staff or elected officials have been out to his property to have a look, despite promises to do so. He said “only Max Weaver has come out, and he has been here several times. (City Administrator) Trout was supposed to come by, and other City Council members, but they never showed up.”
NorthIowaToday.com will follow this story and report the outcome.
Watch video:
This article is from 5 years ago. Did they ever cut the tree down or is it still there?
Hey all you MENSA members, this story was published 4 1/2 years ago. It’s obvious the photos were taken during the summer.
The city just needs to leave this guy alone. 12 feet back from the street is well withing the local ordinance. For some reason they are tying to get even wish and punish the guy. Leave him alone.
Anyone ever heard of reasonable compromise anymore?? These trees and shrubs are certainly not an issue this time of the year so lets back off. In spring when (if) things come back to life lets get with the property owner, work together and trim back what may or may not be a problem. The city and this family have better things to do.
Maybe the guy who killed the trees in front of his home could just girdle this one.
Funny, how an apple tree can be a safety hazard, but putting salt/sand at an intersection where 6 cars went into the ditch. within 2 hours from being icy. isn’t. What is the object here? Public safety, cost saving, laziness or bulliness?? I say leave the tree alone. How many dead or dieing trees in Mason City are there ~ 1/2 of them? Nothing is done about all of them and some are laying on the ground. Just trim tree/bushes up and let this family be..