Breakthrough Web Design - 515-897-1144 - Web sites for businesses
News & Entertainment for Mason City, Clear Lake & the Entire North Iowa Region

Founded October 1, 2010


Rowe takes issue with media coverage of caucus ballot issues


This news story was published on January 25, 2012.
Advertise on NIT Subscribe to NIT

In a letter to Cerro Gordo County Republicans, chairman of the Cerro Gordo County Republican Party John Rowe (pictured) issued the following information to the public in order to help clarify what he says really happened to the ballots that helped decide the winner of the Republican caucuses that were held January 3rd.  Mitt Romney was originally declared the winner by 8 votes, but it is now said that Rick Santorum won by 34 votes.

From John Rowe:

I am very upset at how this is being portrayed that somehow ballots are lost or missing.  This is not the case.  Bear with me while I try to explain.  Each individual precinct has forms that must be filled out and signed, by the temp caucus chair and temp secretary. They are FORM A, SUPPLEMENTAL FORM A, FORM B, FORM C, FORM D AND THE ALL IMPORTANT FORM E.  Every one of the forms, with the exception of FORM E is in triplicate. For whatever reason, FORM E is a single page. It is FORM E that has the individual precinct results, and signed. That form along with the top copies (white page) of all the other forms, AND ALL of the bubble sheets provided by the Auditors office get sent to the RPI Headquarters. Cerro Gordo’s stack that I personally mailed, certified with delivery confirmation, was over 12 inches high. That is just our county….now take that over the other 98 counties and you can begin to imagine the amount of papers they had to sort in Des Moines.

I can assure you…EVERYTHING WAS IN ORDER when I mailed it. We, the county temp chairs, secretaries, building people, central committee and myself did nothing wrong.

I have received so many phone calls today (Thursday,January 20th) from the press. Some were trying to pin the blame on either myself, our county, or the process. Not one reporter I talked to…and it was many today…had any idea to the sheer volume of papers counties had to send in. Most thought it was simply one sheet of paper. When contacted by Bill Schickel a couple of days ago, I told him I have the ballots and the tally sheet from the county where they took the incoming calls for the results. Everything is in order. The state RPI would not allow us to fill out a new FORM E. I am not happy how they portrayed that this is a county issue and made it sound like some ballots were missing, or ballots miscounted. I believe they should have stated that we have all the numbers in, but because FORM E is missing, we cant certify that particular precinct. That would at least show people a better picture of what is wrong.

I take honesty and intergrity very serious. In my business, my reputation is everything. When it is questioned, I take it very serious and personal. Some reporters even wanted to call the precinct chair and secretary. I refused. There is no need to pull them in.  I am the Chair.  I will take the heat. But I can assure that Cerro Gordo County ran a great caucus, we did everything by the book. For that you all are to be thanked.

In the future, it would be nice if the state RPI would make FORM E in triplicate, that way the pink copy gets filed with the Auditors office and that would help clear up any future descrepency.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

 characters available

7 Responses to Rowe takes issue with media coverage of caucus ballot issues

  1. Avatar

    No No No!!! Reply Report comment

    January 30, 2012 at 10:24 pm

    Whatever the reason, it sure ended up to be a real embarrasment for Iowa. Many in the country now think Iowa should be last next time. I hope they get the system fixed for the next time around.

  2. Patrick Palmer

    Patrick Palmer Reply Report comment

    January 25, 2012 at 7:57 pm

    I’m 110% sure that John handled it well and with professionalism. I too have known him and his family for decades and their word has always been good. Form “E” has been a stickler for everyone, including Democrats in past years. Why they don’t have it in triplicate, so one can go to the county auditor and county chair also is beyond me. It’s making good people like John out to be shady, and that’s not fair to those who run a tight ship and care about the process — as John does.

  3. Avatar

    Anonymous Reply Report comment

    January 25, 2012 at 7:19 pm

    YEP, but if this party can’t get its sh- together and its obvious they haven’t and CAN’T right on up to big JOHN B we will be dealing with OBAMA CARE and more!!!!

  4. Avatar

    John Rowe Reply Report comment

    January 25, 2012 at 5:50 pm

    Thanks Craig.I appreciate your words of support. My real problem is RPI never bothered to contact me directly. I feel they threw me under the bus. I can’t speak to what may or may not have happened at the other counties, only what occurred here. And I agree with your other comment about helping out next time. I dont recall anyone who asked, turned away from helping.

  5. Avatar

    Craig Eckhardt Reply Report comment

    January 25, 2012 at 5:38 pm

    Having known John and his family for many, many years, I can assure you that his word is good. I have no doubt what so ever that things happened exactly as he stated in this article. Those that continue to question the process or people involved should step up to the plate and help out next time around. Thanks, John and everyone else for a job well done!

  6. Avatar

    Jerry Goldstein Reply Report comment

    January 25, 2012 at 4:17 pm

    The real story is the media has a liberal bias and are scared of Mr. Mitt Romney running against the current president and are trying their hardest to smear Mitt.

    4 more years of entitlements and change are not what this country needs.

  7. Avatar

    Anonymous Reply Report comment

    January 25, 2012 at 2:05 pm

    Better yet how about we climb into the 21st century and hold an electronic vote, or, even better yet; how about we climb into the 21st century and hold a regular ole primary vote thus increasing turnout. The Iowa caucus system is a joke, and the resulting trouble with the count made Iowa even more of a joke.