MASON CITY – Mason City police are investigating a possible homicide Tuesday morning after a woman was found unresponsive in an apartment.
Mason City police say they responded to 410 North Washington Ave at 12:40 AM concerning a report of suspicious activity. Upon their arrival, they discovered the body of Sarah Dawn Winters, 40, who worked at the Country Club. Winters was unresponsive and paramedics were called to the scene to administer treatment. Winters was transported to Mercy Medical Center where she was later pronounced dead.
Investigation into the incident has lead to the arrest of Aaron John Harris (pictured, bottom), 34, of 410 N. Washington Apartment 101. Harris has been charged with 1st degree murder and is being held in the Cerro Gordo County Jail. The investigation continues, police said.
Sources told NIT that a male resident of 410 N. Washington Ave. had apparently called the building manager, named Hilton, early Tuesday, saying, “I think I killed Sarah!”
When people started to show up at the house, a 14 year-old girl went inside the building and witnessed a man dragging a female down the steps by her ankles. “I was going to say ‘Hi’, but when I saw that the girl had blood coming out of her mouth, I didn’t say anything. I ran out to tell my mom what I saw.”
A witness entering the secured door of the apartment building saw the male dragging a girl out of his apartment. “There was blood coming out of her mouth,” said the witness.
A little while later, another witness saw this same male and a couple of his friends taking her back into the apartment and putting her on a bed.
A resident of the apartment building, who didn’t know quite what was going on because he had been sleeping, said “I have heard these two argue and fight in the past. One time the police were called and they came and escorted the female out of the building. The suspect was yelling at her before that to get out of his apartment and to leave. He was throwing her belongings into the living room.”
This same resident informed, “I had just got up and the Investigator told me that I needed to evacuate the building. I heard other investigators knocking on other doors telling the other residents the same thing. There are eight people that live in the house, I think. When I left, I asked one of the police officers what was going on. They told me that they can’t talk about it, but a very violent crime had happened.”
The apartment house located at 410 North Washington is owned by SHECHEM LLC with an address of 410 South Mitchell Street, Saint Ansgar, Iowa.
SUBJECT IS INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY.

Sherri, Bentley and the rest of the family. I knew “Dawn” as she called herself back then (and you too Sherri) way back when our dads were cops. We moved to Madrid together, lived together went, started new schools together, did everything together for a couple of years. Your mom was an amazing person, Bentley – but you don’t need me to tell you that. I’m so sorry for the horrible stuff people write when something like this happens. Sherri and Kathleen (who I remember as little Kathy) my hearts break for you and your families. I’ve cried and cried reading about this stuff. But not all bad. I have fun, sweet memories of a beautiful girl who could make anyone smile. We had a lot of good times and I’m choosing to remember her that way. My love to all of you. Lisa “King” Johnson.
If any of you commenting do not know my sister or anyone in our family please DO NOT USE THIS for your own personal venting attacks on the city and or government in which you chose to live in.
My sister was taken from her family and daughter in a way she has not deserved!
PLEASE SHOW RESPECT.
Who are the couple of friends that help carry back inside, they need to be in jail also would’nt you think?
I think police should re interview this guy who is a known thief,stalker,physcofrenic, druggie, and likes to smack his girl around not to mention he was the one who stabbed a guy in manly at the thirsty dog years ago. He’s very dangerous.
Someone or some agency MUST make sure the 14 year old girl gets into long-term counceling NOW! She is also a victim of the crime. She is alive, and needs a lot of help processing what she saw, or it could ruin her entire life!
What really annoys me is that the officers didnt offer this 14 yr old counseling after just witnessing a murder!
The problem is that there is a 20-30 year old sub culture in this town that have absolutely nothing to do. They sit on their porches all day after sleeping until noon, walk over to Casey’s for some smokes and a Mountain Dew, check their mail box to see if their food stamps have arrived and do nothing else until night time. Then they go steal from their neighbors since they refuse to get a job. They have no education, no remorse and no guidance. They are simply moronic zombies with no real purpose in life. That is the majority of Mason City’s youth.
iknow the 14 year old, she was going up to get her stepdad & came back down to that, she was not running around, just simply looking for her stepdad, & for the record, NIT was there first, they were the ones who called the police. thanks.
aaron was a kinda sweet hearted person, he was in a faze it was hard to get out of, he was an amazing singer, and awesome dance, sarah was a very pretty lady, may her family be blessed & all involved be blessed to, i cant imagine what that 14 year old is going through…
Could we all take a minute to stop blaming the neighborhood, the police, the city council and drugs, and think of the families of both individuals involved? Mental illnesses were involved and are real diseases that can affect anyone, regardless of where you live and who could have been there “to stop it.” Please take a moment to pray for all those affected, and then think before you put a comment on here that makes you sound ignorant.
I talked with her a couple of times on the bus and not only did she have GREAT outter beauty, her inner beauty was even larger. BE W/JESUS SARAH !
Council Meeting are on the 1st and 3rd Tues of the month. They are held at the mason city library.
“2nd, the police and mayor and all those ppl are not going to do a damn thing until they are pushed to or DCI gets rid of them and brings in some ppl that will.”
Sorry old sock, DCI has no authority within the City of Mason City to interfere with Police operations. They investigate crime along with MCPD, and conduct their own investigations. But all they can do is report to the Attorney General of Iowa, who decides a course of action.
While you are at it, call in the FBI, CIA, NSA, and ATF to take over the PD. Give them a call and see what they say!